![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
Okay then!
Dear Torchwood,
Are you or are you not a show about aliens? Because what with the demons, zombies, and now ghosts, I'M GETTING A LITTLE CONFUSED.
If I want the supernatural I'll watch Supernatural,
Cathryn
Though, to be fair, this episode sucked so hard that maybe it WAS about aliens. Lord knows the MotW didn't make any sense. They are images that were trapped on film! And they were always evil! And they appeared out of nowhere - no, wait, sorry, out of the rain! And the one chick is a mermaid!
And okay, if they were apparitions that appeared during rainstorms to collect souls or whatever in the guise of travelling performers, and thenvideo killed the radio star cinema killed the travelling show, what happened? If they were apparitions, why wouldn't they keep appearing anyway? If they were something a little less ethereal, did they just fail to adapt? I can work with the idea of images on old film being like ghosts (I think I first saw it in an Animaniacs or possibly Tiny Toons parody of Field of Dreams actually), but not if the subjects of the images were already ghosts. Pick a story, Torchwood!
Either way, though, they could be killed by filming them and exposing the film. Fine, okay. Except then they tried to make it science-y and I just don't know, this episode sucked out loud. I hardly expect Torchwood to make sense, because it, like, doesn't, but it is capable of sufficient storytelling logic to keep me from going, "Wait, what?" every two minutes.
I don't even feel like dissecting character stuff because the episode was too dumb. I won't even get on Jack for his continued douchery in re: Owen. I will, however, laugh at the show for going from Jack hating the idea of sending Owen into a physically dangerous situation, to Jack grudgingly allowing Owen to volunteer for a physically dangerous situation, to Jack sending him into one without a second thought within the space of three episodes. I thought it would take at least four. (One could argue that Jack sent Owen up because of Owen's whole not having a last breath of life to steal thing. To which I say that Owen still could have gotten hurt, and he was limping down the stairs as it was, and OH MY GOD THIS EPISODE SUCKED AND MADE NO SENSE. This is why I wasn't going to get into character choices. Because they all sucked and made no sense.)
This is only the third episode that I've found unwatchable on the first viewing, which, for a show of such dubious quality, is pretty damn good. The other two were "Cyberwoman," which actually proved to be pretty damn funny when I made myself sit through it again, and "Adam," though I seem to be in the minority there. Appropriately enough, I do believe that the nurse or whatever in this episode was played by the pizza girl from "Cyberwoman."
Brief aside - why the fuck does all the good canon backstory come from shitty episodes with this show? "Cyberwoman" remains Ianto's only major (onscreen) character development. "Small Worlds," which was okay on the first viewing but bored me to death on the second, had Estelle, one of the few substantial parts of Jack's history that this show has gone into. And now we have "From Out of the Rain," which, incoherent as it was, managed to dole out another solid piece of information about Jack's past. Why is the show making me choose between learning about the characters' lives or watching enjoyable television?
In conclusion, a show like this is a crapshoot and sometimes you lose big.
Dear Torchwood,
Are you or are you not a show about aliens? Because what with the demons, zombies, and now ghosts, I'M GETTING A LITTLE CONFUSED.
If I want the supernatural I'll watch Supernatural,
Cathryn
Though, to be fair, this episode sucked so hard that maybe it WAS about aliens. Lord knows the MotW didn't make any sense. They are images that were trapped on film! And they were always evil! And they appeared out of nowhere - no, wait, sorry, out of the rain! And the one chick is a mermaid!
And okay, if they were apparitions that appeared during rainstorms to collect souls or whatever in the guise of travelling performers, and then
Either way, though, they could be killed by filming them and exposing the film. Fine, okay. Except then they tried to make it science-y and I just don't know, this episode sucked out loud. I hardly expect Torchwood to make sense, because it, like, doesn't, but it is capable of sufficient storytelling logic to keep me from going, "Wait, what?" every two minutes.
I don't even feel like dissecting character stuff because the episode was too dumb. I won't even get on Jack for his continued douchery in re: Owen. I will, however, laugh at the show for going from Jack hating the idea of sending Owen into a physically dangerous situation, to Jack grudgingly allowing Owen to volunteer for a physically dangerous situation, to Jack sending him into one without a second thought within the space of three episodes. I thought it would take at least four. (One could argue that Jack sent Owen up because of Owen's whole not having a last breath of life to steal thing. To which I say that Owen still could have gotten hurt, and he was limping down the stairs as it was, and OH MY GOD THIS EPISODE SUCKED AND MADE NO SENSE. This is why I wasn't going to get into character choices. Because they all sucked and made no sense.)
This is only the third episode that I've found unwatchable on the first viewing, which, for a show of such dubious quality, is pretty damn good. The other two were "Cyberwoman," which actually proved to be pretty damn funny when I made myself sit through it again, and "Adam," though I seem to be in the minority there. Appropriately enough, I do believe that the nurse or whatever in this episode was played by the pizza girl from "Cyberwoman."
Brief aside - why the fuck does all the good canon backstory come from shitty episodes with this show? "Cyberwoman" remains Ianto's only major (onscreen) character development. "Small Worlds," which was okay on the first viewing but bored me to death on the second, had Estelle, one of the few substantial parts of Jack's history that this show has gone into. And now we have "From Out of the Rain," which, incoherent as it was, managed to dole out another solid piece of information about Jack's past. Why is the show making me choose between learning about the characters' lives or watching enjoyable television?
In conclusion, a show like this is a crapshoot and sometimes you lose big.
Tags:
![[identity profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/openid.png){kind=small}
From:
no subject
Oh, god. This is such a complicated question. (Because the fandom is batshit, that's why.) The thing is that John is a very divisive character - he's a good man, but not the kindest father by a long shot, and there's a tendency by a rather substantial chunk of fandom to vilify him, with the end result being that the majority of John/Dean (there is very, very little John/Sam) is non-con horribleness. I am not a fan. What I look for is fic that acknowledges John as a man who does the best he can by his sons, while all the while being a very fucked up individual because of how his wife died and probably also a nice case of PTSD from fighting in the Vietnam war. I put together a supernatural fic rec post (http://catslash.livejournal.com/352345.html#cutid2) a while back that includes some of my favorite John/Dean, plus there's more in my memories under "fic" if you care though plow through. I really should organize those.
I do rather hope you *went* to sleep at this juncture.
I did! Eventually. And it's late again, but I don't have to get up so early and I'm trying to fit in "The Sound of Drums"/"The Last of the Time Lords" before the premiere, which my work schedule is making complicated, so here I am. Not quite as fuzzy as before. Or something.
I am going to savor every moment of anticipation tomorrow, because it's totally going to be the best part
plus I'm hoping that the more I trash talk the finale in advance, the more the universe will decide to prove me wrong.From:
no subject
From:
no subject